Self-identity discrepancy theory: Exploring returning South African Cuban-trained medical students sense of belonging
Abstract
Background: The Nelson Mandela-Fidel Castro Collaboration programme (NMFCMC) between South Africa and Cuba was established in 1996. South African students, undergo five years of medical training in Cuba and finish the final eighteen months of training in South Africa. These students experience academic difficulties on their return.
Methods: All twelve NMFCMC students enrolled at the University of KwaZulu-Natal in 2015 participated in this study. Data were elicited using focus group interviews, narrative interviews, found photovoice and the Collage Life Story Elicitation Technique. Results: Challenges faced by participants resulted in identity discrepancy, which in turn promoted unfavourable attitudes, affect, psychological and physical behaviours towards participants’ belongingness. Conclusion: Returning NMFCMC students experienced difficulties in assimilation due to identity discrepancies and frustrated sense of belonging. Focusing on reinforcing positive aspects of identity, and interpersonal relationships through moderating the tendency of local teachers and students to emphasise the “otherness” of the NMFCMC student is crucial.References
Alsulami, Naif Daifullah Z. 2021. “Challenges Of The Re-Entry Experiences Of Returning Saudi International Students After Studying Abroad.” Journal of Comparative & International Higher Education 13(4): 101‒117.
Aydin, Selami. 2013. “Factors Affecting the Level of Test Anxiety among EFL Learners at Elementary Schools.” Online Submission 4(1): 63‒81.
Bandura, Albert. 1982. “Self-efficacy mechanism in human agency.” American Psychologist 37(2): 122.
Baumeister, Roy F. and Davina A. Robson. 2021. “Belongingness and the modern schoolchild: On loneliness, socioemotional health, self‒esteem, evolutionary mismatch, online sociality, and the numbness of rejection.” Australian Journal of Psychology 73(1): 103‒111.
Baumgardner, Ann H. 1990. “To know oneself is to like oneself: Self-certainty and self-affect.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 58(6): 1062.
Berkowitz, Leonard. 1990. “On the formation and regulation of anger and aggression: A cognitive-neoassociationistic analysis.” American Psychologist 45(4): 494.
Berkowitz, Leonard. 2014. “Towards a general theory of anger and emotional aggression: Implications.” Perspectives on Anger and Emotion: Advances in Social Cognition 6.
Brunsting, Nelson C., Corinne Zachry, and Risa Takeuchi. 2018. “Predictors of undergraduate international student psychosocial adjustment to US universities: A systematic review from 2009‒2018.” International Journal of Intercultural Relations 66: 22‒33.
Busch, F. N., M. Rudden, and T. Shapiro. 2004. “Psychodynamic treatment of depression: Development of a psychodynamic model of depression.” Arlington: American Psychiatric Publishing: 13‒30.
Busch, Fredric N. 2009. “Anger and depression.” Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 15(4): 271‒278.
Campbell, Jennifer D. 1990. “Self-esteem and clarity of the self-concept.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 59(3): 538.
Carver, Charles S., John W. Lawrence, and Michael F. Scheier. 1999. “Self-discrepancies and affect: Incorporating the role of feared selves.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 25(7): 783‒792.
Chattopadhyay, Prithviraj, Elizabeth George, and Sandra A. Lawrence. 2004. “Why does dissimilarity matter? Exploring self-categorization, self-enhancement, and uncertainty reduction.” Journal of Applied Psychology 89(5): 892.
Chattu, Vijay Kumar, Pradeep Kumar Sahu, Neela Seedial, Gerlisa Seecharan, Amanda Seepersad, Melina Seunarine, Shivanna Sieunarine, Kahamaron Seymour, Samantha Simboo, and Arissa Singh. 2020. “An exploratory study of quality of life and its relationship with academic performance among students in medical and other health professions.” Medical Sciences 8(2): 23.
Connelly, F. Michael, and D. Jean Clandinin. 2006. “Narrative Inquiry.” In Handbook of complementary methods in education research., 477‒487. Mahwah, NJ, US: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.
Cooley, Charles Horton. 2017. Human nature and the social order. Routledge.
Correa, Christopher A., Michelle Perry, Linda M. Sims, Kevin F. Miller, and Ge Fang. 2008. “Connected and culturally embedded beliefs: Chinese and US teachers talk about how their students best learn mathematics.” Teaching and Teacher Education 24(1): 140‒153.
Daniels, Ana Z. and Kristy Holtfreter. 2019. “Moving beyond anger and depression: The effects of anxiety and envy on maladaptive coping.” Deviant Behavior 40(3): 334‒352.
DeJordy, Rich. 2008. “Just passing through: Stigma, passing, and identity decoupling in the work place.” Group & Organization Management 33(5): 504‒531.
Dewey, John. 1937. “Education and social change.” Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors (1915‒1955) 23(6): 472‒474.
Dollard, John, Leonard W. Doob, N. E. Miller, O. H. Mowrer, and R. R. Sears. 1939. Frustration and aggression. New Haven, Yale University Press.
Donda, B. M., R. J. Hift, and V. S. Singaram. 2016. “Assimilating South African medical students trained in Cuba into the South African medical education system: Reflections from an identity perspective.” BMC Medical Education 16(1): 1‒7.
Dörnyei, Zoltan and Dale Griffee. 2010. “Research Methods in Applied Linguistics.” TESOL Journal 1. https://doi.org/10.5054/tj.2010.215611.
Earle, Timothy C. 2009. “Trust, confidence, and the 2008 global financial crisis.” Risk Analysis: An International Journal 29(6): 785‒792.
Earle, Timothy C., Michael Siegrist, and Heinz Gutscher. 2010. “Trust, risk perception and the TCC model of cooperation.” In Trust in Risk Management, 18‒66. Routledge.
Ebaeguin, Marlon. 2015. Promoting Teacher Growth through Lesson Study: A Culturally Embedded Approach. Mathematics Education Research Group of Australasia.
Erikson, Erik H. 1994. Identity and the life cycle. WW Norton & company.
Frable, Deborrah E., Tamela Blackstone, and Carol Scherbaum. 1990. “Marginal and mindful: Deviants in social interactions.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 59(1): 140.
Gasiorek, Jessica and Kris Van de Poel. 2014. “‘We feel stupid and we shouldn’t.’ Towards developing a communication support system for Cuban-trained medical students.” Per Linguam: A Journal of Language Learning = Per Linguam: Tydskrif vir Taalaanleer 30(1): 71‒92.
Gerull, Katherine M., Priyanka Parameswaran, Donna B. Jeffe, Arghavan Salles, and Cara A. Cipriano. 2021. “Does medical students’ sense of belonging affect their interest in orthopaedic surgery careers? A qualitative investigation.” Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research® 479(10): 2239‒2252.
Ghosh, Cyril. 2018. “De-Moralizing Gay Rights.” In De-Moralizing Gay Rights, 1‒9. Springer.
Given, Lisa M. 2008. The Sage encyclopedia of qualitative research methods. Sage publications.
Goffman, Erving. 1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Kindle edition. Touchstone.
Goodenow, Carol. 1993. “Classroom belonging among early adolescent students: Relationships to motivation and achievement.” The Journal of Early Adolescence 13(1): 21‒43.
Han, Suejung, M. Carole Pistole, and Jarred M. Caldwell. 2017. “Acculturative stress, parental and professor attachment, and college adjustment in Asian international students.” Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development 45(2): 111‒126.
Harter, Susan. 1999. “Symbolic interactionism revisited: Potential liabilities for the self constructed in the crucible of interpersonal relationships.” Merrill-Palmer Quarterly (1982‒): 677‒703.
Higgins, E. Tory. 1987. “Self-discrepancy: A theory relating self and affect.” Psychological Review 94(3): 319.
Higgins, Peter. 2021. “Covering and the moral duty to resist oppression.” Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 24(7): 1068‒1075.
Holstein, James A. and Jaber F. Gubrium. 2012. “Introduction: Establishing a balance.” In Varieties of narrative analysis, 1‒11.
Hu, Guangwei. 2002. “Potential cultural resistance to pedagogical imports: The case of communicative language teaching in China.” Language Culture and Curriculum 15(2): 93‒105.
Jin, Ling and Chiachih D. C. Wang. 2018. “International students’ attachment and psychological well-being: The mediation role of mental toughness.” Counselling Psychology Quarterly 31(1): 59‒78.
Jindal-Snape, Divya and David J. Miller. 2008. “A challenge of living? Understanding the psycho-social processes of the child during primary-secondary transition through resilience and self-esteem theories.” Educational Psychology Review 20(3): 217‒236.
Jindal-Snape, Divya and David J. Miller. 2009. “Understanding transitions through self-esteem and resilience.” In Educational transitions, 25‒46. Routledge.
Johns, Adam and Lorna Peters. 2012. “Self-discrepancies and the situational domains of social phobia.” Behaviour Change 29(2): 109‒125.
Jordan, Cathie. 1985. “Translating culture: From ethnographic information to educational program.” Anthropology & Education Quarterly 16(2): 105‒123.
Jovchelovitch, S. 2000. Narrative interviewing in Qualitative Researching with text, image and sound: A practical handbook, ed. M. W. Bauer and G. Gaskell. Thousand Oaks, London, New Delhi: Sage Publications.
Kim, Kawon, Margaret E. Ormiston, Matthew J. Easterbrook, and Vivian L. Vignoles. 2019. “Ethnic dissimilarity predicts belonging motive frustration and reduced organizational attachment.” Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 22(1): 116‒138.
Kimbrel, Nathan A. 2008. “A model of the development and maintenance of generalized social phobia.” Clinical Psychology Review 28(4): 592‒612.
Krueger, Richard A. 2014. Focus groups: A practical guide for applied research. Sage publications.
Leary, Mark R. 2021. “Emotional reactions to threats to acceptance and belonging: A retrospective look at the big picture.” Australian Journal of Psychology 73(1): 4‒11.
Leary, Mark R. and Geoff MacDonald. 2003. “Individual differences in self-esteem: A review and theoretical integration.” In Handbook of self and identity, ed. M. R. Leary and J. P. Tangney, 401–418. The Guilford Press.
Lindley, Jennifer, Louise McCall, and Adela Abu-Arab. 2013. “Visitor or inhabitant? Addressing the needs of undergraduate transnational medical students.” Journal of Studies in International Education 17(1): 79‒96.
Lohr, Jeffrey M., Bunmi O. Olatunji, and Craig N. Sawchuk. 2007. “A functional analysis of danger and safety signals in anxiety disorders.” Clinical Psychology Review 27(1): 114‒126.
Lowinger, Robert Jay, Ben C. H. Kuo, Hyun-A. Song, Lakshmi Mahadevan, Eunyoung Kim, Kelly Yu-Hsin Liao, Catherine Y. Chang, Kyong-Ah Kwon, and Suejung Han. 2016. “Predictors of academic procrastination in Asian international college students.” Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice 53(1): 90‒104.
Lungelow, Danielle. 2011. The experience of students in the South African-Cuban medical training program: An encounter with medical pluralism. University of Cape Town.
MacDonald, Geoff and Mark R. Leary. 2005. “Why does social exclusion hurt? The relationship between social and physical pain.” Psychological Bulletin 131(2): 202.
Makonye, Judah Paul. 2020. “Towards a culturally embedded Financial Mathematics PCK framework.” Research in Mathematics Education 22(2): 98‒116.
Marcussen, Kristen. 2006. “Identities, self-esteem, and psychological distress: An application of identity-discrepancy theory.” Sociological Perspectives 49(1): 1‒24.
Markus, Hazel and Paula Nurius. 1986. “Possible selves.” American Psychologist 41(9): 954.
Martin, Andrew J. and Herbert W. Marsh. 2003. “Fear of failure: Friend or foe?” Australian Psychologist 38(1): 31‒38.
Mesidor, Jean Kesnold, and Kaye F. Sly. 2016. “Factors that contribute to the adjustment of international students.” Journal of International Students 6(1): 262‒282.
Motala, Munirah and Jacqueline Van Wyk. 2019. “Where are they working? A case study of twenty Cuban-trained South African doctors.” African Journal of Primary Health Care & Family Medicine 11(1): 1‒9.
Newheiser, Anna-Kaisa and Manuela Barreto. 2014. “Hidden costs of hiding stigma: Ironic interpersonal consequences of concealing a stigmatized identity in social interactions.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 52: 58‒70.
Ng, Thomas W. H., Kelly L. Sorensen, Ying Zhang, and Frederick H. K. Yim. 2019. “Anger, anxiety, depression, and negative affect: Convergent or divergent?” Journal of Vocational Behavior 110: 186‒202.
Niwa, Erika Y., Niobe Way, and Diane L. Hughes. 2014. “Trajectories of ethnic‐racial discrimination among ethnically diverse early adolescents: Associations with psychological and social adjustment.” Child Development 85(6): 2339‒2354.
Oyserman, Daphna and Hazel Markus. 1990. “Possible selves in balance: Implications for delinquency.” Journal of Social Issues 46(2): 141‒157.
Pachankis, John E. 2007. “The psychological implications of concealing a stigma: A cognitive-affective-behavioral model.” Psychological Bulletin 133(2): 328.
Phasha, Tshegofatso Sylvia. 2021. The transitional experiences of South African medical students returning from Cuba. University of Pretoria.
Polkinghorne, Donald E. 1995. “Narrative configuration in qualitative analysis.” International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education 8(1): 5‒23.
Rapee, Ronald M. and Richard G. Heimberg. 1997. “A cognitive-behavioral model of anxiety in social phobia.” Behaviour Research and Therapy 35(8): 741‒756.
Rehman, Sana and Zenis Baluja. 2021. “Evaluation of knowledge, attitude and practice regarding stress management among undergraduate medical students at tertiary care teaching hospital, New Delhi.” IP International Journal of Comprehensive and Advanced Pharmacology 6(2): 83‒88.
Rose, G. 2006. Visual methodologies: An introduction to interpreting visual materials. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage Publications Ltd.
Sagar, Sam S., Bradley K. Busch, and Sophia Jowett. 2010. “Success and failure, fear of failure, and coping responses of adolescent academy football players.” Journal of Applied Sport Psychology 22(2): 213‒230.
Sareen, Jitender, Brian J. Cox, Ian Clara, and Gordon J. G. Asmundson. 2005. “The relationship between anxiety disorders and physical disorders in the US National Comorbidity Survey.” Depression and Anxiety 21(4): 193‒202.
Schubert, Thomas W. and Sabine Otten. 2002. “Overlap of self, ingroup, and outgroup: Pictorial measures of self-categorization.” Self and Identity 1(4): 353‒376.
Seligman, Martin E. P., Steven F. Maier, and Richard L. Solomon. 1971. “Aversive Conditioning and Learning.” In Chapter 6 ‒ Unpredictable and uncontrollable aversive events, 347‒400. Academic Press.
Shankar, P. Ravi, Aisha Cox, Grissel Leon, Elumalai Kumaresan, and G. Dakubo. 2018. “Stress and Coping Strategies among Undergraduate Nursing and Medical Students at American International Medical University, St Lucia.” Education in Medicine Journal 10(4).
Stopa, Lusia and David M. Clark. 2000. “Social phobia and interpretation of social events.” Behaviour Research and Therapy 38(3): 273‒283.
Sui, Xincheng, Priscilla Reddy, Anam Nyembezi, Pamela Naidoo, Kalipso Chalkidou, Neil Squires, and Shah Ebrahim. 2019. “Cuban medical training for South African students: A mixed methods study.” BMC Medical Education 19(1): 1‒11.
Sullivan, Christopher and Susan Kashubeck-West. 2015. “The interplay of international students’ acculturative stress, social support, and acculturation modes.” Journal of International Students 5(1): 1‒11.
Tajfel, Henri, John C. Turner, William G. Austin, and Stephen Worchel. 1979. “An integrative theory of intergroup conflict.” Organizational identity: A reader 56(65): 9780203505984-16.
Tangney, June P., Patricia Wagner, Carey Fletcher, and Richard Gramzow. 1992. “Shamed into anger? The relation of shame and guilt to anger and self-reported aggression.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 62(4): 669.
Tovote, Philip, Jonathan Paul Fadok, and Andreas Lüthi. 2015. “Neuronal circuits for fear and anxiety.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 16(6): 317‒331.
Van Schalkwyk, Gertina J. 2010. “Collage Life Story Elicitation Technique: A Representational Technique for Scaffolding Autobiographical Memories.” Qualitative Report 15(3): 675‒695.
Waterval, Dominique, Janneke M. Frambach, Stephen M. Scott, Erik W. Driessen, and Albert J. J. A. Scherpbier. 2018. “Crossborder curriculum partnerships: Medical students’ experiences on critical aspects.” BMC Medical Education 18(1): 1‒9.
Waterval, Dominique G. J., Janneke M. Frambach, Andrea Oudkerk Pool, Erik W. Driessen, and Albert J. J. A. Scherpbier. 2016. “An exploration of crossborder medical curriculum partnerships: Balancing curriculum equivalence and local adaptation.” Medical Teacher 38(3): 255‒262.
Watson, David, Jerry Suls, and Jeffrey Haig. 2002. “Global self-esteem in relation to structural models of personality and affectivity.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 83(1): 185.
Weeks, Justin W., Richard G. Heimberg, and Thomas L. Rodebaugh. 2008. “The Fear of Positive Evaluation Scale: Assessing a proposed cognitive component of social anxiety.” Journal of Anxiety Disorders 22(1): 44‒55.
Weeks, Justin W., Richard G. Heimberg, Thomas L. Rodebaugh, and Peter J. Norton. 2008. “Exploring the relationship between fear of positive evaluation and social anxiety.” Journal of Anxiety Disorders 22(3): 386‒400.
Wei, Meifen, Ya-Shu Liang, Yi Du, Raquel Botello, and Chun-I Li. 2015. “Moderating effects of perceived language discrimination on mental health outcomes among Chinese international students.” Asian American Journal of Psychology 6(3): 213.
Wells, Adrian, David M. Clark, and Sameena Ahmad. 1998. “How do I look with my minds eye: Perspective taking in social phobic imagery.” Behaviour Research and Therapy 36(6): 631‒634.
Yoshino, Kenji. 2001. “Covering.” Yale Law Journal 111: 769.
Zimmer-Gembeck, Melanie J., Drew Nesdale, Haley J. Webb, Mhasa Khatibi, and Geraldine Downey. 2016. “A longitudinal rejection sensitivity model of depression and aggression: Unique roles of anxiety, anger, blame, withdrawal and retribution.” Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology 44(7): 1291‒1307.
Zungu, Sibongile Brenda, Kenneth M. Mathu, and Caren Brenda Scheepers. 2019. “Leading the South African Cuban-trained medical students’ assimilation in the local medical schools.” Emerald Emerging Markets Case Studies 9(2): 1‒17. https://doi.org/10.1108/EEMCS-11-2018-0249.
Copyright (c) 2022 Buhle Maud Donda, Veena Singaram, Richard Hift
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
This journal is an open access journal, and the authors and journal should be properly acknowledged, when works are cited.
Authors, copyright holders, may use the publishers version for teaching purposes, in books, theses, dissertations, conferences and conference papers.
A copy of the authors' publishers version may also be hosted on the following websites:
- Non-commercial personal homepage or blog.
- Institutional webpage.
- Authors Institutional Repository.
The following notice should accompany such a posting on the website: This is an electronic version of an article published in SAJHE, Volume XXX, number XXX, pages XXX “XXX", DOI. Authors should also supply a hyperlink to the original paper or indicate where the original paper (http://www.journals.ac.za/index.php/SAJHE) may be found.
Authors publishers version, affiliated with the Stellenbosch University will be automatically deposited in the University Institutional Repository SUNScholar.
Articles as a whole, may not be re-published with another journal.
The following license applies:
Attribution CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
