Leading article: A meta-reflection on my emerging as a scholar of action research

  • P.H. du Toit University of Pretoria


The self-enquiry reported in this article is conducted at a meta-level of meaning making. A meta-level of reflection is typical of a meta-cognitive mind-set; it entails reflecting on my reflection from a scholarly point of view. The theory on whole brain thinking informs the conceptual framework for my research and teaching practice; therefore I have given new meaning to action research as being whole brain action research, reflection as whole brain reflection, and for the purpose of this article specifically, whole brain meta-reflection. My scholarly reflections focus on what is reported in publications. Data sets gathered over the years are not reported per se as it has already been made public. Instead, I reflect at macro level on existing data. What is made public by means of this article is my reflection on my reflections in the past. It is inevitable that the raw data I have drawn from forms the core of my article. Therefore, a great number of references indicate me as author or co-author.

Author Biography

P.H. du Toit, University of Pretoria

Department of Humanities Education

Associate professor


Beckman, J. L., J. W. van Rooyen, J. J. Conradie, H. J. Joubert and P. H. du Toit. 2002. Technical report Outcomes-based school leadership and management (Eastern Cape, Free State and Limpopo) (Project7). Pretoria: University of Pretoria.

Beckman, J. L., J. W. van Rooyen, J. J. Conradie, H. J. Joubert, P. H. du Toit and G. Meyer. 2002. Technical report 2002: Outcomes-based school leadership and management: An in-service training programme for school principals in the Northern Province (Project 7). Pretoria: University of Pretoria.

Biggs, J. B. 1985. The role of metalearning in study processes. British Journal of

Educational Psychology 55: 185–212.

T. Chisanga, G. Ashu, P. Mavume, N. Dhlula-Moruri, M. Khatry-Chhetry, S. Rajkaran, L. Mulenga, N. Sotshangane, N. Gonsalves, P. H. du Toit and D. Pillay. 2017. The vanda, the rose, and the baobab: Inspirational display objects as fertile sites for opening up narratives of teacher researcher professional identities. In Object medleys interpretive possibilities for educational research, D. Pillay, K. Pithouse-Morgan and I. Naicker eds., 63-80. Rotterdam: Sense Publishers.

Christensen, L. B., R. B. Johnson and L.A. Turner. 2014. Research Methods, design, and analysis. Boston (England): Pearson.

De Boer, A-L., P. H. du Toit and T. Bothma. 2015. Activating whole brain® innovation: A means of nourishing multiple intelligence in higher education. TD The Journal for Transdisciplinary Research in Southern Africa 11(2): 55–72.

De Jager, T. 2011. Beginner-teacher professional development: An action research

approach to mentoring. MEd dissertation, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa.

Du Toit, P. H. 2001a. Learning style flexibility. Multiple Intelligence Conference, 21 June, Baptist University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong.

Du Toit, P. H. 2001b. Professional portfolio building – alternative assessment

strategy in teacher education. Educare 30(1 & 2): 326–346.

Du Toit, P. H. 2004a. Learning styles. In Keys to education psychology I. Eloff and L.

Ebersöhn, eds., 145–163. Cape Town: UCT Press.

Du Toit, P. H. 2004b. Reflecting on the sounds of ALARPM 6th and PAR 10th World

Congresss 2003 in Pretoria, South Africa – a persononalised lullaby for four drums.

Action Learning Action Research Journal 9(1):3–27.

Du Toit, P. H. 2008a. A personal reflection on the SAARDHE International

Conference, 2007. South African Journal of Higher Education, 22(6): 1131–1137

Du Toit, P. H. 2008b. Matching learning style flexibility and action research for academic staff development. AERA Conference, 24-28 March, New York.

Du Toit, P. H. 2009. An action research approach to monitoring one’s professional development as manager: Pretoria: Foundation for Professional Development.

Du Toit, P. H. 2011. Departing from home to tandem with a peer – a scholarly

approach to intrapersonal leadership PEER Symposium, 22 September, University

of Macquarie, Sydney.

Du Toit, P. H. 2012. Using action research as process for sustaining knowledge

production: A case study of a higher education qualification for academics. South

African Journal of Higher Education 26(6): 1216–1233.

Du Toit, P. H. 2015. From the first ALARPM World Congress in Pretoria to the next ALARA in Pretoria: What happened in between? A meta-reflection by the first South African ALARPM convenor. Celebrating 25 years of ALARA contributions: Developing a learning conference culture. ALARA Conference, 4-7 November, St George Hotel, Pretoria.

Du Toit, P. H. 2016a. Action research as innovative means to self-study: A quest for 'thinking out of my box'! Keynote address: SAIDE/OER Africa convening, 17-18 May 2016, Nairobi, Kenya.

Du Toit, P. H. 2016b. An ethnographic account of a snapshot in Prof Graham

Duncan’s journey of educational professionalism. HTS Teologiese

Studies/Theological Studies, 72(1), a3275 http://dx.doi.org/101402.v72i1.3275

Du Toit, P. H. 2017. A pair of scissors, 15 A-4 pages and cello tape: A

constructivist equation to making meaning of self-regulated and cooperative

learning. International Research Symposium and Exhibition. “Not just an object”:

Making meaning of and from everyday objects in educational research, 3-5 February,

Maharani Hotel, Durban.

Du Toit, P. H. 2018. Study manual for Professional Development (PFO) and

Mediating Learning (LMD), Pretoria: University of Pretoria.

Du Toit, P. H. and S. Vandeyar. 2003. Innovative portfolio assessment – portfolios as

Performance assessment tool. In Outcomes-

based assessment, J. G. Maree and W. J. Fraser, eds., 120–141. Sandown:


Du Toit, P. H. and P. van Petegem. 2005a. Cultivating agents of change in education needs change agents in teacher education. 50th ICET World Assembly, 12-15 July, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

Du Toit, P. H. and P. van Petegem. 2005b. Learning style flexibility for effective

virtual teams. In Teaching and learning in virtual teams, S. P. Ferris and S. Godar,

eds., 32–52. Hershey: Information Science Publishing.

Fringe, J. 2013. Critical reflection as essential principle of professional development

of academic staff. PhD thesis, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa.

Giloi, S. and P. H. du Toit. 2013. Current approaches to the assessment of graphic

design in a Higher Education context. International Journal of Arts and Design

Education 32(2): 256–268.

Greyling, W. J. and P. H. du Toit. 2008. Pursuing a constructivist approach to

mentoring in the higher education sector. South African Journal of Higher Education

(5): 948–956.

Hugo, J. F. M., J. Slabbert, J. M. Louw, T. S. Marcus, M. Bac, M., P. H. Du Toit and

J. E. Sandars. 2013. The clinical associate curriculum: The learning theory

underpinning the BCMP programme at the University of Pretoria. African Journal of

Health Professions Education, 4(2): 128–131.

Le Cornu, R. 2005. Peer mentoring: Engaging pre-service teachers in mentoring one another. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 13(3): 355–366.

Lichtman, M. 2014. Qualitative research for the social sciences. California: SAGE.

Malan, S. P. T. and P. H. du Toit, red. 1991. Suksesvolle onderrig. Riglyne vir

dosente, onderwysers en opleiers. [Successful teaching: Guidelines for lecturers,

teachers and trainers] Pretoria: Academica.

Malan, S.P.T., P. H. Du Toit, and L. J. van Oostrum, eds. 1996. Successful teaching:

Guidelines for lecturers, teachers and trainers. Bureau for Academic Support Services,

University of Pretoria.

McNiff, J. and J. Whitehead. 2006. All you need to know about action research.

London: SAGE.

O’Leary, Z. 2014. The Essential Guide to doing your Research Project. London: SAGE.

Schön, D. A. 1995. The new scholarship requires a new epistemology. Change


Smit, T. and P. H. du Toit. 2016. Transforming beginner teacher mentoring interventions for social reform. South African Journal of Education, 36(3). Available at: http://reference.sabinet.co.za/sa_epublication/educat Art.#1134,12 pages.

Doi: 10.15700/saje.v36n3a1134

Tembe, C. 2011. Exploring professional development interventions for improving the teaching practice of primary school teachers. PhD thesis, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

Van Oordt, M.L., T. van Oordt, and P.H. du Toit. 2014. Are two teachers better than one? Meditari Accountancy Research 22(2): 165–185.

Van Petegem, P. and P. H. du Toit. 2005. Is what students see, what they get? Reflections on curriculum development in higher education: A case study. Scientia Experimentalis XLI(1):125–144.

Wagenaar, T. C. & E. Babbie. 2004. Guided activities for the practice of social research. Australia: Wadsworth.

Wolvaardt, E. Over the conceptual horizon of Public Health: A living theory of teaching undergraduate medical students. PhD thesis, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

How to Cite
du Toit, P.H. 2018. “Leading Article: A Meta-Reflection on My Emerging As a Scholar of Action Research”. South African Journal of Higher Education 32 (6), 425-39. https://doi.org/10.20853/32-6-3019.