Identification and critique of the citizenship notion informing the Itorero training scheme for high school leavers in post-genocide Rwanda
AbstractThere is a dearth of research on citizenship education in post-genocide countries. The present article investigates the citizenship concept informing Itorero, a non-formal citizenship education platform meant for High School Leavers (hereafter HSLs) in post-genocide Rwanda. To this end, the paper engages with classical notions of citizenship (civic republicanism, liberalism and communitarianism), and modern ones (cosmopolitanism and radical democracy) in a bid to identify the notion deemed preferable to competing notions. It is revealed that the Itorero training relies heavily on the civic republican/communitarian concepts of citizenship. The paper argues that while these concepts contain constructive elements, such as fostering courage, self-sacrifice, patriotism, connectedness, and common good concern, excessive pursuit of this citizenship model might not be helpful for post-genocide Rwanda. The civic republican/communitarian paradigm – as it is practiced in Itorerotraining – is likely to produce uncritical, docile, dependent, short-sighted and child-like citizens; it encourages fanaticism.
Abowitz, K. K. and J. Harnish. 2006. Contemporary discourses of citizenship. Review of Educational Research 76(4): 653-690.
Adejumobi, S. 2001. Citizenship, rights and the problem of conflicts and civil wars in Africa. Human Rights Quarterly 23: 148-170.
Adeyemi, M. B. and A. A. Adeyinka. 2003. The principles and content of African traditional education. Educational Philosophy and Theory 35(4): 425-440.
Ake, C. 1996. Rethinking African democracy. In The global resurgence of democracy, ed. L. Diamond and M. Plattner, 63-75. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Antal, C. and P. Easton. 2009. Indigenizing civic education in Africa: experience in Madagascar and the Sahel. International Journal of Educational Development 29: 599-611.
Appiah, K. A. 2008. Education for global citizenship. Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of Education 107(1): 83-99.
Arthur, J. 1998. Communitarianism: what are the implications for education? Education Studies 24(3): 353-368.
Arthur, J., I. Davies and C. Hahn, eds. 2008. The SAGE handbook of education for citizenship and democracy. London: SAGE.
Audi, R. 2009. Nationalism, patriotism, and cosmopolitanism in an age of globalization. The Journal of Ethics 13(4): 365-381.
Avineri, S. and A. De-Shalit, eds. 1992. Communitarianism and individualism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bailey, R. 1998. Teaching values and citizenship across the curriculum. Glasgow: Kogan Page Limited.
Benhabib, S. 2002. The claims of culture: equality and diversity in the global era. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Carney, S. 1992. Liberalism and communitarianism. A misconceived debate. Political Studies 40: 273-289.
Carr, D. 1991. Educating the virtues. An essay on the philosophical psychology of moral development and education. London and New York: Routledge.
Chioncel, N. and T. Jansen. 2004. Reviewing education and training for governance and active citizenship in Europe – A central and eastern European perspective. Project RE-ETGACE.
Codère, H. 1973. The biography of an African society, Rwanda 1900–1960. Tervuren: Musée Royal de l’Afrique Centrale.
Davies, L. 2005. Teaching about conflict through citizenship education. International Journal of Citizenship and Teacher Education 1(2): 17–34.
Delanty, G. 2000. Citizenship in a global age. Society, culture, politics. Buckingham: Open University Press.
Enslin, P. and K. Horsthemke. 2004. Can Ubuntu provide a model for citizenship education in African democracies? Comparative Education 40(4): 545-558.
Etzioni, A. 1993. The spirit of community: rights, responsibilities and the communitarian agenda. New York: Crown.
Faulks, K. 2000. Citizenship. London: Routledge.
Freedman, S. W., H. M. Weinstein, K. Murphy and T. Longman. 2008. Teaching history after identity‐based conflicts: the Rwanda experience. Comparative Education Review 52(4): 663-690.
Galston, A. W. 1988. Liberal virtues. The American Political Science Review 82(4): 1277-1290.
Government of Rwanda. Law N° 41/2013 of 16/06/2013 establishing the National Itorero Commission and determining its mission, organization and functioning, Rwanda Official Gazette N° 29 of 22 July 2013.
Gutmann, A. 1996. Democratic citizenship. In For Love of country: debating the limits of patriotism, ed. J. Cohen, 66-71. Boston: Beacon Press.
Gutmann, A. 2002. Civic minimalism, cosmopolitanism, and patriotism: where does democratic education stand in relation to each? Nomos 43: 23-57.
Habermas, J. 1994. Three normative models of democracy. Constellations 1(1): 1- 10.
Harber, C. 1997. Education, democracy and political development in Africa. Brighton: Sussex Academic Press.
Harrisson, C. and B. Baumgartl. 2002. Stocktaking research on policies on education for democratic citizenship and management of diversity in South- East Europe. Regional analysis and intervention proposals. Council of Europe, GIV/EDU/CIT (2001) 45, Final Regional Report.
Heater, D. 1990. Citizenship: the civic ideal in world history, politics and education. London: Longman.
Heater, D. 2004. A brief history of citizenship. New York: New York University Press.
Honohan, I. 2002. Civic Republicanism. Oxfordshire: Taylor and Francis.
Isin, E. F. and B. S. Turner, eds. 2002. Handbook of citizenship studies. London: Sage.
Kabwete Mulinda, C. 2002. La généalogie de l’idée du peuplement du Rwanda: considérations sur l’autochtonie ou l’allochtonie des Rwandais. In Peuplement du Rwanda. Enjeux et perspectives, eds. F. Rutembesa, E. Ntaganda and J. Murwanashyaka, 49-72. Butare : Editions de l’Université Nationale du Rwanda.
Kartal, F. 2002. Liberal and republican conceptualizations of citizenship: a theoretical inquiry. Turkish Public Administration Annual 27-28: 101- 130.
King, E. 2013. From classrooms to conflict in Rwanda. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Koutselini, M. 2008. Citizenship education in context: student teacher perceptions of citizenship in Cyprus. Intercultural Education 19(2): 163-175.
Kymlicka, W. 1997. Education for citizenship. Political Science Series 40: 1-25.
Kymlicka, W. and W. Norman. 1994. Return of the citizen: a survey of recent work on citizenship theory. Ethics 104(2): 352-381.
Maison des Jeunes de Kimisagara. 2008. Rapport de la recherche sur l’ecole traditionnelle du Rwanda (Itorero). Kigali, Janvier – Mars
Marshall, T. H. 1964. Class, citizenship and social development. New York: Doubleday & Company, Inc.
Mgbako, C. 2005. Ingando solidarity camps: reconciliation and political indoctrination in post-genocide Rwanda. Harvard Human Rights Journal 18: 201-224.
Mhlauli, M. V. 2012. The role of education on citizenship development in Africa. British Journal of Arts and Social Sciences 4(1): 104-115.
Miller, D. 1998. Bounded Citizenship. In Cosmopolitan citizenship, ed. K. Hutchings and R. Dannreuther, 60-80. London: Macmillan.
Ministry of Education. 2008. Social Studies Curriculum, Grade 1-6. Kigali, Rwanda.
Mouffe, C. 1992. Citizenship and political identity. The Identity in Question 61: 28-32.
Mulhall, S. and A. Swift. 2007. Liberals and communitarians. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
National Itorero Commission. 2011. National Itorero Commission Strategy. Kigali, November.
National Itorero Commission. 2012. Volunteerism Policy Paper. Kigali, July.
National Unity and Reconciliation Commission. 2009. Itorero ry’Igihugu. Policy Note and Strategic Plan. Kigali, June.
Ndaruhutse, E. 2008. Les compagnies ‘Amatorero’ au Rwanda ancien et contemporain. Mémoire de Licence, Kigali Institute of Education.
Neff, S. 1998. International law and the critique of cosmopolitan citizenship. In Cosmopolitan citizenship, eds. K. Hutchings and R. Dannreuther, 105-119. London: Macmillan.
Neubauer, T. 2012. A critical review of international studies into citizenship and citizenship education - Lessons for citizenship education in Slovenia. Journal of Social Science Education 11(1): n.p.
Nussbaum, C. 1994. Patriotism and cosmopolitanism. Boston Review 19(5): 3-34.
Ogot, B. A. 1999. Building on the indigenous: selected essays 1981-1988. Kisumu: Anyange Press.
Oliver, D. and D. Heater. 1994. The foundations of citizenship. Hertfordshire: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
Osaghae, E. E. 2006. Colonialism and civil society in Africa. The perspective of Ekeh’s two publics. Voluntas 17: 233-245.
Osler, A. and H. Starkey. 2003. Learning for cosmopolitan citizenship: theoretical debates and young people's experiences. Educational Review 55(3): 243- 254.
Osler, A. and H. Starkey. 2005. Changing citizenship. Democracy and inclusion in education. New York: Open University Press.
Otiende, J. E. and O. Oanda. 2000. Social studies in Kenya. In Social studies in African education, ed. M. B. Adeyemi, 205-215. Gaborone: Pyramid.
Phelan, S. 2001. Sexual strangers: gays, lesbians and dilemmas of citizenship. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Prunier, G. 1995. The Rwanda crisis. History of a genocide. Columbia University Press.
Purdekovà, A. 2011. Rwanda’s Ingando camps: liminality and the reproduction of power (No. 80). Refugee Studies Centre, Working Paper.
Quaynor, L. J. 2015. Researching citizenship education in Africa: considerations from Ghana and Liberia. Research in Comparative and International Education 10(1): 120-134.
Ramphele, M. 2001. Citizenship challenges for South Africa's young democracy. Daedalus 130(1): 1-17.
Reilly, J. and U. Niens. 2014. Global citizenship as education for peacebuilding in a divided society: structural and contextual constraints on the development of critical dialogic discourse in schools. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 44(1): 53-76.
Riesenberg, P. 1992. Citizenship in the western tradition: Plato to Rousseau. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Sandel, M. J. 1982. Liberalism and the limits of justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sandel, M. J. 1999. Liberalism and republicanism: friends or foes? The Review of Politics 61(2): 209-214.
Shyaka, A. (n.d). The Rwandan conflict: origin, development and exit strategies. National Unity and Reconciliation Commission. Kigali.
Smith, W. 2007. Cosmopolitan citizenship: virtue, irony and worldliness. European Journal of Social Theory 10(1): 37-52.
Staeheli, L. A. and D. Hammett. 2010. Educating the new national citizen: education, political subjectivity and divided societies. Citizenship Studies 14(6): 667-680.
Sundberg, M. 2014. Training for model citizenship: an ethnography of civic education and state-making in Rwanda. PhD Thesis, Uppsala University.
Taylor, C. 1989. Sources of the self: the making of the modern identity. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
Tomasi, J. 2001. Liberalism beyond justice: citizens, society and the boundaries of political theory. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Torney-Purta, J., R. Lehmann, H. Oswald and W. Schulz. 2001. Citizenship and education in twenty-eight countries: civic knowledge and engagement at age fourteen. Amsterdam: IEA Secretariat.
Tuomi, M. T., L. Jacott and U. Lundgren. 2008. Education for world citizenship: preparing students to be agents of social change. CiCe Thematic Network Project.
Turner, S. 2014. Making good citizens from bad life in post‐genocide Rwanda. Development and Change 45(3): 415-433.
Van Steenbergen, B. 1994. The condition of citizenship. London: Sage Publications.
Vansina, J. 2004. Antecedents to modern Rwanda: the Nyiginya kingdom. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Vogel, U. and M. Moran. 1991. The frontiers of citizenship. New York: St. Martin's Press.
Waghid, Y. 2006. Deliberation and citizenship: closing some of the gaps related to the "Values in Education" initiative in South Africa. South African Journal of Education 24(4): 278-283.
Waghid, Y. 2007. Educating for democratic citizenship and cosmopolitanism. South African Journal of Higher Education 21(5): 584-595.
Walzer, M. 1989. Citizenship. In Political innovation and conceptual change, eds. T. Ball, J. Farr, R. L. Hanson, 211–220. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wayne, R. E. 2004. Negotiating the politics of citizenship education. Political Science and Politics 37(2): 249-251.
Young, I. M. 1989. Polity and group difference: a critique of the ideal of universal citizenship. Ethics 99: 250-274.
Copyright (c) 2017 DR SYLVESTRE NZAHABWANAYO
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This journal is an open access journal, and the authorsÂ and journal should be properly acknowledged, when works are cited.
Authors, copyright holders, may use the publishers version for teaching purposes, in books, theses, dissertations, conferences and conference papers.Â
A copy of the authors' publishers version may also be hosted on the following websites:
- Non-commercial personal homepage or blog.
- Institutional webpage.
- Authors Institutional Repository.
The following notice should accompany such a posting on the website: This is an electronic version of an article published in SAJHE, Volume XXX, number XXX, pages XXX “XXX", DOI. Authors should also supply a hyperlink to the original paper or indicate where the original paper (http://www.journals.ac.za/index.php/SAJHE) may be found.
Authors publishers version, affiliated with the Stellenbosch University will be automatically deposited in the University Institutional Repository SUNScholar.
Articles as a whole, may not be re-published with another journal.
The following license applies:
Attribution CC BY-NC-ND 4.0