Effects of demographic factors on provision of feedback in postgraduate medical education

C.I. Bagwandeen, V.S. Singaram


A key element in the process of clinical medical education is the process of providing feedback by comparing the directly observed performance of postgraduate doctors training to become specialists to that of a previously identified and communicated ‘gold standard’ and incorporating a plan for improvement. This is regarded as crucial to enhance clinical competencies. Hence, a greater understanding of the clinical educational environment and the various factors that impact on the giving and receiving of feedback within such a setting is required.

A mixed methods approach was adopted for this observational study regarding the perceptions of the quality of feedback given and received at a large multicultural teaching hospital. Relationships between demographics and certain important aspects of the provision of feedback were observed which impact on the context in which feedback is given and received. The study found that appropriate strategies should be implemented to improve teaching capacity of consultants, together with gender empowerment and academic support programmes for registrars. 


Feedback; quality; registrars; consultants; demographics; clinical environment

Full Text:




Anderson, Peter A.M. "Giving feedback on clinical skills: are we starving our young?" Journal of Graduate Medical Education 4, no. 2 (2012): 154-158.

Archer, Julian C. "State of the science in health professional education: effective feedback." Medical Education 44, no. 1 (2010): 101-108.

Badat, Saleem. 2015. “Deciphering the Meanings and Explaining the South African Higher Education Student Protests of 2015 - 16.” Wits Institute for Social and Economic Research. http://wiser.wits.ac.za/system/files/documents/.

Badat, Saleem. "Theorising institutional change: post‐1994 South African higher education." Studies in Higher Education 34, no. 4 (2009): 455-467.

Bagwandeen, Chauntelle I., and Veena S. Singaram. "Feedback as a means to improve clinical competencies: Consultants’ perceptions of the quality of feedback given to registrars." African Journal of Health Professions Education 8, no. 1 (2016a): 113-116.

Bagwandeen, Chauntelle I., and Veena S. Singaram. "Feedback as a means to improve clinical competencies: Registrars’ perceptions of the quality of feedback provided by consultants in an academic hospital setting." African Journal of Health Professions Education 8, no. 1 (2016b): 117-120.

Bing-You, Robert G., and Robert L. Trowbridge. "Why medical educators may be failing at feedback." Journal of the American Medical Association, 302, no. 12 (2009): 1330-1331.

Boehler, Margaret L., David A. Rogers, Cathy J. Schwind, Ruth Mayforth, Jacquelyn Quin, Reed G. Williams, and Gary Dunnington. "An investigation of medical student reactions to feedback: a randomised controlled trial." Medical Education 40, no. 8 (2006): 746-749.

Branch Jr, William T., and Anuradha Paranjape. "Feedback and reflection: teaching methods for clinical settings." Academic Medicine 77, no. 12, Part 1 (2002): 1185-1188.

Brindley, Peter G., Katherine E. Smith, Pierre Cardinal, and Francois LeBlanc. "Improving medical communication: skills for a complex (and multilingual) clinical world." Canadian Respiratory Journal 21, no. 2 (2014): 89-91.

Busari, Jamiu O., Nielske M. Weggelaar, Andrieke C. Knottnerus, Petra‐Marie Greidanus, and Albert J.J.A. Scherpbier. "How medical residents perceive the quality of supervision provided by attending doctors in the clinical setting." Medical Education 39, no. 7 (2005): 696-703.

Cantillon, Peter, and Joan Sargeant. "Giving feedback in clinical settings." British Medical Journal, 337, no. nov10_2 (2008): a1961-a1961.

Cornell University: A Strategic Plan 2010 – 2015. [Internet]. [cited 2016 Dec 8]. Available from: https://www.cornell.edu/strategicplan/ 2010.

Creswell, John W. Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. New York: Sage Publications, 2013.

Daelmans, Hester, E. M., Rene M. Overmeer, H. H. van der Hem‐Stokroos, Albert J. J. A. Scherpbier, Coen D. A. Stehouwer, and Cees P. M. van der Vleuten. "In‐training assessment: qualitative study of effects on supervision and feedback in an undergraduate clinical rotation." Medical Education 40, no. 1 (2006): 51-58.

Daniel, CarolAnn. "Outsiders-within: Critical race theory, graduate education and barriers to professionalization." Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare 34 (2007): 25-43.

Davis, Georgiann, and Rachel Allison. "Increasing representation, maintaining hierarchy: An assessment of gender and medical specialization." Social Thought and Research 32 (2013): 17-45.

Drinkwater, Jess, Mary Patricia Tully, and Tim Dornan. "The effect of gender on medical students’ aspirations: a qualitative study." Medical Education 42, no. 4 (2008): 420-426.

Ende, J., 1983. Feedback in clinical medical education. Journal of the Americam Medical Association, 250(6):.777-781.

Ferguson, Eamonn, David James, and Laura Madeley. "Factors associated with success in medical school: systematic review of the literature." British Medical Journal, 324, no. 7343 (2002): 952-957.

Fernando, Nishan, Jennifer Cleland, Hamish McKenzie, and Kevin Cassar. "Identifying the factors that determine feedback given to undergraduate medical students following formative mini‐CEX assessments." Medical Education 42, no. 1 (2008): 89-95.

Jussim, Lee, HsiuJu Yen, and John R. Aiello. "Self-consistency, self-enhancement, and accuracy in reactions to feedback." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 31, no. 4 (1995): 322-356.

Kilminster, Sue, Julia Downes, Brendan Gough, Deborah Murdoch‐Eaton, and Trudie Roberts. "Women in medicine− is there a problem? A literature review of the changing gender composition, structures and occupational cultures in medicine." Medical Education 41, no. 1 (2007): 39-49.

Kogan, Jennifer R., Lisa N. Conforti, Elizabeth C. Bernabeo, Steven J. Durning, Karen E. Hauer, and Eric S. Holmboe. "Faculty staff perceptions of feedback to residents after direct observation of clinical skills." Medical Education 46, no. 2 (2012): 201-215.

Lee, Katherine B., Sanjeev N. Vaishnavi, Steven KM Lau, and Dorothy A. Andriole. "Cultural competency in medical education: demographic differences associated with medical student communication styles and clinical clerkship feedback." Journal of the National Medical Association 101, no. 2 (2009): 116-126.

McQueen, Sydney A., Bradley Petrisor, Mohit Bhandari, Christine Fahim, Victoria McKinnon, and Ranil R. Sonnadara. "Examining the barriers to meaningful assessment and feedback in medical training." The American Journal of Surgery 211, no. 2 (2016): 464-475.

Mezirow, Jack. "Transformative learning: Theory to practice." New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education 1997, no. 74 (1997): 5-12.

Murdoch‐Eaton, Deborah, and Joan Sargeant. "Maturational differences in undergraduate medical students’ perceptions about feedback." Medical Education 46, no. 7 (2012): 711-721.

Murdoch‐Eaton, Deborah. "Feedback: the complexity of self‐perception and the transition from ‘transmit’to ‘received and understood’." Medical Education 46, no. 6 (2012): 538-540.

Nelson, Mary Lee, and Elizabeth L. Holloway. "Relation of gender to power and involvement in supervision." Journal of Counselling Psychology 37, no. 4 (1990): 473-481

Nicol, David J., and Debra Macfarlane‐Dick. "Formative assessment and self‐regulated learning: A model and seven principles of good feedback practice." Studies in Higher Education 31, no. 2 (2006): 199-218.

Odom, Kara L., Laura Morgan Roberts, Rachel L. Johnson, and Lisa A. Cooper. "Exploring obstacles to and opportunities for professional success among ethnic minority medical students." Academic Medicine 82, no. 2 (2007): 146-153.

Ramani, Subha, and Sharon K. Krackov. "Twelve tips for giving feedback effectively in the clinical environment." Medical Teacher 34, no. 10 (2012): 787-791.

Redden, Elizabeth. 2015. “In South Africa, Push Continues for Free Tuition and Adequate Support.” Inside Higher Education. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2015/11/18/south-africa-push-continues-free-tuition-and-adequate-support.

Rose, Gail L., Margaret R. Rukstalis, and Marc A. Schuckit. "Informal mentoring between faculty and medical students." Academic Medicine 80, no. 4 (2005): 344-348.

Ruggs, Enrica, and Michelle Hebl. "Literature overview: Diversity, inclusion, and cultural awareness for classroom and outreach education." Apply research to practice (ARP) resources. Retrieved from https ://www. engr. psu. edu/awe/ARPAbstracts/DiversityInclusion/ARP_ DiversityInclusionCulturalAwareness_Overview.pdf (2012).

Sender Liberman, A., Moishe Liberman, Yvonne Steinert, Peter McLeod, and Sarkis Meterissian. "Surgery residents and attending surgeons have different perceptions of feedback." Medical Teacher 27, no. 5 (2005): 470-472.

Shrivastava, Saurabh, Prateek Shrivastava, and Jegadeesh Ramasamy. "Effective feedback: An indispensable tool for improvement in quality of medical education." Journal of Pedagogic Development 4, no. 1 (2014):12-20

Sinclair, Hazel K., and Jennifer A. Cleland. "Undergraduate medical students: who seeks formative feedback?" Medical Education 41, no. 6 (2007): 580-582.

Singh, Simerjit, Dinker R. Pai, Nirmal K. Sinha, Avneet Kaur, Htoo Htoo Kyaw Soe, and Ankur Barua. "Qualities of an effective teacher: what do medical teachers think?" BMC Medical Education 13, no. 1 (2013): 1.

Thomas, Jane DeLima, and Robert M. Arnold. "Giving feedback." Journal of Palliative Medicine 14, no. 2 (2011): 233-239.

Van de Ridder, J. M., Karel M. Stokking, William C. McGaghie, and Olle Th J. Ten Cate. "What is feedback in clinical education?" Medical Education 42, no. 2 (2008): 189-197.

Wittich, Christopher M., Karen F. Mauck, Jayawant N. Mandrekar, Karol A. Gluth, Colin P. West, Scott C. Litin, and Thomas J. Beckman. "Improving participant feedback to continuing medical education presenters in internal medicine: a mixed-methods study." Journal of General Internal Medicine 27, no. 4 (2012): 425-431.

Woolf, Katherine, Henry W.W. Potts, and I. C. McManus. "Ethnicity and academic performance in UK trained doctors and medical students: systematic review and meta-analysis." British Medical Journal, 342 (2011):135-159.

Zehra, Tabassum, Muhammad Tariq, Afaq Motiwala, Syeda Kauser Ali, and John Boulet. "Challenges of providing timely feedback to Residents: Faculty perspectives." Journal of Pakistan Medical Association 65, no. 10 (2015): 1069-1074.

Zhang, Anthony Lin, Charlie Changli Xue, and Harry HS Fong. "Integration of herbal medicine into evidence-based clinical practice", in Herbal Medicine: Biomolecular and Clinical Aspects (second ed), edited by Iris F. F. Benzie and Sissi Wachtel-Galor. Boca Raton, CRC Press. (2011) Chapter 22

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20853/32-1-1657


  • There are currently no refbacks.

eISSN: 1753-5913

Copyright © 2016 South African Journal of Higher Education

Hosted by Stellenbosch University Library and Information Service since 2016.

Creative Commons License -CC BY-NC-ND 4.0

This journal is hosted by the SU LIS on request of the journal owner/editor. The SU LIS takes no responsibility for the content published within this journal, and disclaim all liability arising out of the use of or inability to use the information contained herein. We assume no responsibility, and shall not be liable for any breaches of agreement with other publishers/hosts.