Academic pipeline or academic treadmill? Postdoctoral fellowships and the circular logic of "development"
Abstract
South African higher education policy related to postdoctoral fellowships is informed by two related discourses: the discourse of the “academic pipeline” and the discourse of “human capital development”. Both of these are forward-looking concepts which imply that good things lie in future employment for postdocs, and/or increased competitiveness and employment for the nation. This article, which is part autoethnography and part higher education policy analysis, offers a critique of these discourses by narrating the author’s own transition from postgraduate psychology student to contract worker, postdoctoral fellow, unsuccessful permanent job applicant, and finally to accepting an offer of a permanent academic job outside South Africa. While seeing myself as one of these early-career academics in the “pipeline” which the policy documents purport to address, I discuss how research managers use discourses of career development and human capital development to mislead young academics about their academic employment prospects and silence their attempts to critique the system. The article proposes that the concept of the academic pipeline works to obscure how postdoctoral fellowships are part of the casualisation and de-professionalisation of academic work, through which disciplinary identity and accomplishments are being divorced from secure university employment.
References
Allais, Stephanie. 2017. “Towards measuring the economic value of higher education: Lessons from South Africa.” Comparative Education 53(1): 147‒163. DOI: 10.1080/03050068.2017.1254985.
Balwanz, D. and S. Ngcwangu. 2016. “Seven problems with the ‘scarce skills’ discourse in South Africa.” South African Journal of Higher Education 30(2): 31‒52.
Brown, P. 2003. “The opportunity trap: Education and employment in a global economy.” European Educational Research Journal 2(1): 141‒178.
Brown, P. 2013. “Education, opportunity, and the prospects for social mobility.” British Journal of Sociology of Education 34(5‒6): 678‒700. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/ 01425692.2013.816036.
Collins, R. 2011. Credential inflation and the future of universities. Italian Journal of Sociology of Education 2: 228‒251.
Cornelissen, J. J. and A. S. van Wyk. 2007. “Professional socialisation: An influence on professional development and role definition.” South African Journal of Higher Education 21(7): 826‒841.
Department of Science and Technology. 2016. “Human capital development strategy for research, innovation and scholarship.” https://www.dst.gov.za/index.php/resource-center/strategies-and-reports/2349-human-capital-development-strategy-for-research-innovation-and-scholarship.
Department of Higher Education and Training. 2015. “The New Generation of Academics Programme (nGAP).” https://www.dhet.gov.za/ssauf/ngap.html.
DHET see Department of Higher Education and Training.
DST see Department of Science and Technology.
Gill, Rosalind. 2014, “Academics, cultural workers and critical labour studies.” Journal of Cultural Economy 7(1): 12‒30. https://doi.org/10.1080/17530350.2013.861763.
Harley, Anne. 2017 “Editorial”. Education as Change 21(3): 1‒14. https://doi.org/10.17159/1947-9417/2017/3489.
Hlengwa, A. 2019. “How are institutions generating the next generation of university teachers?” Critical Studies in Teaching and Learning 7(1): 1‒18. DOI:10.14426/cristal.v7i1.170.
Holley, K., A. Kuzhabekova, N. Osbaldiston, F. Cannizzo, C. Mauri, S. Simmonds, et al. 2018. “Global perspectives on the postdoctoral scholar experience.” In The postdoc landscape: The invisible scholars, ed. A Jaeger and A. Dinin, 203‒226. London: Academic Press.
Invisible Adjunct. 2003a. “Thinking about graduate school in the humanities?” http://www.invisibleadjunct.com/archives/000004.html. (Accessed 10 September 2021).
Invisible Adjunct. 2003b. “Still thinking about graduate school in the humanities?” http://www.invisibleadjunct.com/archives/000037.html. (Accessed 6 September 2021).
Invisible Adjunct. 2003c. “PhD as preparation for nonacademic careers?” http://www.invisibleadjunct.com/archives/000006.html. (Accessed 23 September 2021).
Janz, Bruce. 2015. “Instrumentalisation in universities and the creative potential of race.” In Being at home: Race, institutional culture and transformation at South African higher education institutions, ed. Pedro Tabensky and Sally Matthews, 273‒296. Pietermaritzburg: UKZN Press.
Kelsky, Karen. 2015. The professor is in. Three Rivers Press.
Kerr, P. 2020. “Postdoctoral fellows and the economics of promises.” Thought Leader 22 November 2020. https://thoughtleader.co.za/postdoctoral-fellowships-and-the-economics-of-promises/. (Accessed 8 September 2021.)
Kerr, P. 2020. “Postdoctoral fellowships are wasting the skills and expertise of postdoctoral fellows.” Mail & Guardian, May 2020. https://mg.co.za/education/2020-05-31-perverse-incentives-for-universities-are-wasting-the-skills-and-work-of-postdoctoral-fellows/. (Accessed 8 September 2021.)
Kerr, P. 2021. “Are we in a parallel pipeline? Bringing the casualisation of academic work onto the higher education agenda in South Africa.” Transformation 105: 25‒49.
Kerr, P. 2022. “Career development or career delay? Postdoctoral fellowships and the de-professionalising of academic work in South African universities.” British Journal of Sociology of Education 43(4): 550‒565. https://doi.org/10.1080/01425692.2022.2045902.
Kimber, M. 2003. “The tenured core and the tenuous periphery: The casualisation of academic labour in Australian universities.” Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 25(1): 41‒50
Mail & Guardian. 2008. “Taxing research?” https://mg.co.za/article/2008-09-23-taxing-research/. (Accessed 8 September 2021).
Maistry, S. 2019. “(Re)counting the high cost of predatory publishing and the effect of a neoliberal performativity culture.” Journal of Education 75: 5‒19. http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/2520-9868/i75a01.
Malloy, J., L. Young, and L. Berdahl. 2021. “PhD oversupply: The system is the problem.” Inside Higher Ed, 22 June 2021. https://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2021/06/22/how-phd-job-crisis-built-system-and-what-can-be-done-about-it-opinion?utm_source=Inside%20Higher%20 Ed&utm_campaign=6a3ba1669f-DNU_2021_COPY_02&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_ 1fcbc04421-6a3ba1669f-197798121&mc_cid=6a3ba1669f&mc_eid=0f8dd88db4&fbclid= IwAR3PXxEa4Z4jdgN5Z7dyv-P5WSq23zCXuHpOO5c0WQl4x81GzLK7fm62c2c.
Martin, B. 2009. “Academic patronage.” International Journal for Educational Integrity 5(1): 3‒19.
Maseti, Thandokazi. 2018. “The university is not your home: Lived experiences of a black woman in academia.” South African Journal of Psychology 48(3): 343‒350. 10.1177/0081246318792820.
May, R., D. Peetz, and G. Strachan. 2013. “The casual academic workforce and labour market segmentation in Australia.” Labour and Industry: A Journal of the Social and Economic Relations of Work 23(3): 258‒275.
McKenzie, L. 2021. “Reading academic quit lit – how and why precarious scholars leave academia.” LSE Impact Blog 18 August 2021. https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2021/08/18/ reading-academic-quit-lit-how--why-precarious-scholars-leave-academia/.
Morgan, G. 2016. “Cannibalising the collegium: The plight of the humanities and social sciences in the managerial university.” In Academic labour, unemployment and global higher education: Neoliberal policies of funding and management, edited by S. Gupta, J. Habjan, and H. Tutek, 151‒165. London: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI 10.1057/978-1-137-49324-8_9.
Mouton, Johann. 2018. “Building a cadre of emerging scholars for higher education in South Africa.” Report commissioned by Department of Science and Innovation. https://www.dst.gov.za/ images/2018/Emerging-Scholars_22.pdf. (Accessed May 2019).
Msimanga, A. 2017. “The supervisory process and development of scholarship: Reflections on three journeys.” In Strengthening postgraduate supervision, ed. S. McKenna, J. Clarence-Fincham, C. Boughey, H. Wells, and H. van den Heuwel, 21‒30. Stellenbosch: SUN Media.
Muller, Sean. 2017. “Academics as rent-seekers: Distorted incentives in higher education, with reference to the South African case.” International Journal of Educational Development 52: 58‒67.
Murgia, Annelisa and Barbara Poggio. Ed. 2019. Gender and precarious research careers: A comparative analysis. Oxford and New York: Routledge.
Muthama, E. and Sioux McKenna. 2020. “The unintended consequences of using direct incentives to drive the complex task of research dissemination.” Education as Change 24(1): 1‒23.
National Research Foundation. 2021. “Freestanding, Innovation, and Scarce Skills Postdoctoral Fellowships: Framework.” https://www.nrf.ac.za/funding/call-documents/scholarship-and-fellowship-application-documents-2022/.
National Research Foundation. 2022. “South African Research Chairs Initiative.” https://www.nrf.ac.za/core-mandate-business-divisions/risa-directorates/research-chairs-and-centres-of-excellence-rcce/south-african-research-chairs-initiative/. (Accessed 25 July 2022).
NRF see National Research Foundation.
OECD. 2021. “Reducing the precarity of academic research careers”. OECD Science, Technology and Industry Policy Papers, no. 113. OECD Publishing.
Phil (no surname). 2015. “When tenured professors and administrators are on the same side.” Texts and Pleasure 11 September 2015. http://www.textsandpleasure.com/2015/09/when-tenured-professors-and.html. (Accessed 3 March 2022).
Rothengatter, M. and R. Hil. 2013. “A precarious presence: Some realities and challenges of academic casualisation in Australian universities.” Australian Universities Review 55(2): 51‒59.
Ryan, S., J. Burgess, J. Connell, and E. Groen. 2013. “Casual academic staff in an Australian university: Marginalised and excluded.” Tertiary Education and Management 19(2): 161‒175. 10.1080/13583883.2013.783617.
Servage, L. 2009. “Alternative and professional doctorates: What is driving the demand?” Studies in Higher Education 34(7): 765‒779.
Simmonds, Shan and Eli Bitzer. 2018. “The career trajectories of postdocs in their journeys of becoming researchers.” In A scholarship of doctoral education, ed. P. du Preez and S. Simmonds, 275‒293. Stellenbosch: SUN Press,
Stewart, P. 2007. “Re-envisioning the academic profession in the shadow of corporate managerialism.” Journal of Higher Education in Africa 5(1): 131‒147.
Swartz, R., M. Ivancheva, L. Czierniewicz, and N. Morris. 2019. “Between a rock and hard place: Dilemmas regarding the purpose of public higher education in South Africa”. Higher Education 77: 567‒583.
Tomlinson, M. and R. Watermeyer. 2020. “When masses meet markets: Credentialism and commodification in twenty-first century Higher Education.” Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education. https://doi.org/10.1080/01596306.2020.1814996
Tsampiras, Carla. 2017. “Chaos, complexity and contexts: Some considerations for supervision.” In Strengthening postgraduate supervision, ed. S. McKenna, J. Clarence-Fincham, C. Boughey, H. Wells, and H. van den Heuwel, 31‒48. Stellenbosch: SUN Media.
Zulu, N. T. 2021. “The struggles and triumphs of South African black women professors.” South African Journal of Higher Education 35(6): 239‒257.
Copyright (c) 2022 Philippa Kerr
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
This journal is an open access journal, and the authors and journal should be properly acknowledged, when works are cited.
Authors, copyright holders, may use the publishers version for teaching purposes, in books, theses, dissertations, conferences and conference papers.
A copy of the authors' publishers version may also be hosted on the following websites:
- Non-commercial personal homepage or blog.
- Institutional webpage.
- Authors Institutional Repository.
The following notice should accompany such a posting on the website: This is an electronic version of an article published in SAJHE, Volume XXX, number XXX, pages XXX “XXX", DOI. Authors should also supply a hyperlink to the original paper or indicate where the original paper (http://www.journals.ac.za/index.php/SAJHE) may be found.
Authors publishers version, affiliated with the Stellenbosch University will be automatically deposited in the University Institutional Repository SUNScholar.
Articles as a whole, may not be re-published with another journal.
The following license applies:
Attribution CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
